Preston's YouTube Thumbnail Evolution Strategy

For gaming YouTubers like Preston, nailing that perfect thumbnail can mean the difference between millions of clicks or getting lost in the sea of content.

If you're a content creator looking to grow your audience, studying successful channels like Preston’s is a great place to start. In this blog, we’ll dive deep into how Preston’s thumbnails have evolved, the strategies behind them, and how you can create eye-catching thumbnails just like him. Whether you're watching on a desktop or mobile device, Preston’s thumbnails are built to grab attention.

Let’s break down how Preston’s dynamic thumbnail strategy keeps his audience hooked and what AI thumbnail makers can do to help you create stunning thumbnails effortlessly. Ready to boost your own thumbnails? Let’s get started!

Kelly Preston YouTube Channel Overview

YouTube channel overview image for Preston in the search without YouTube thumbnail images.

Preston's channel is all about energy, fun, and family-friendly content. He focuses on gaming, especially Minecraft, but also includes challenges and vlogs that show his upbeat personality. Here's a quick snapshot of his channel stats:

  • Subscribers: 28 million+
  • Total Videos: 4.1k+
  • Total Views: Over 10.6 billion
  • Joined On: July 4, 2012

Preston’s Thumbnail Evolution: A Closer Look

Preston’s thumbnails have evolved over the years, reflecting his growth as a content creator and his ability to keep up with YouTube trends. Let's break down the types of thumbnails you’ll find on his channel.

Challenge Thumbnails

Challenge YouTube thumbnail from Kelly Preston's YouTube channel with perfect aspect ratio for a YouTube thumbnail

Preston’s challenge videos often feature him in action, surrounded by props that relate to the challenge. Whether he's scaling walls or pranking friends, these thumbnails showcase him doing something exciting, making viewers eager to click. Bold text is often used, with sharp colors and visual clues that hint at the fun inside.

Reaction Thumbnails

Reaction YouTube thumbnail from a Kelly Preston YouTube video.

Preston’s reaction thumbnails are packed with exaggerated facial expressions. His excitement or surprise is front and center, drawing viewers in to see what he’s reacting to. These types of thumbnails are perfect for gaming updates or trends, where viewers want to see genuine reactions.

Gaming Thumbnails

Gaming YouTube thumbnail from Kelly Preston's YouTube Channel video.

Gaming is Preston's bread and butter, and his gaming thumbnails often include his avatar or face alongside popular game characters or environments. Bright colors and strong contrast make these thumbnails pop, especially on mobile devices.

Collaborative Thumbnails

Collaborative YouTube thumbnail from the search of YouTube.

Preston loves collaborating with top YouTubers like MrBeast and his wife, Brianna. These thumbnails feature split screens or multi-screen layouts, showing Preston and the collaborators side by side. It’s visually engaging, and fans of both creators are drawn in immediately.

Vlog Thumbnails

Vlog YouTube thumbnail for a Kelly Preston video.

Vlog thumbnails on Preston’s channel are more relaxed, often showing casual, real-life moments. These thumbnails might highlight a location, a personal event, or a behind-the-scenes look at his life. They’re great for connecting with the audience on a more personal level.

Comparison Thumbnails

Comparison YouTube thumbnail for a video.

Preston also uses side-by-side images in his comparison thumbnails, such as “before and after” shots. These thumbnails are ideal for videos like "Expectation vs. Reality" or game tutorials, where visual comparisons are key.

Tutorial Thumbnails

Tutorial YouTube thumbnail for a video on search.

In his early days, Preston used tutorial thumbnails that were clean and simple, with step-by-step images or numbered elements. These designs focused more on game screenshots and offered a clear message to viewers about what they could learn.

YouTube Video Thumbnails Journey: Preston's Evolution from Basic to Bold

Preston’s YouTube thumbnails have undergone a significant transformation since he started his channel, evolving alongside his content to meet the demands of his growing audience. In this section, we’ll take a closer look at how his thumbnails have changed over time, reflecting not just his growth as a content creator but also the shifting trends in YouTube’s visual landscape. Let’s break down Preston’s thumbnail journey into three key stages: The Early Stage, The Transition Phase, and The Bold Era.

Early Stage: Simple and Straightforward

Early YouTube thumbnail that are templates.

In the beginning, Preston’s thumbnails were much simpler. He relied heavily on raw in-game screenshots, especially from Minecraft, with minimal editing. During this time, there was little to no emphasis on creating thumbnails that grabbed attention or conveyed a sense of excitement. The focus was on letting the game visuals speak for themselves.

Design Elements

Thumbnails mainly featured a single in-game screenshot with no additional elements like text or overlays. The colors were mostly flat, and the thumbnails lacked depth or dynamism.

Text Usage

Very little or no text was used in the thumbnails, which made them less compelling to viewers scrolling through their feed.

Viewer Impact

While these thumbnails worked for a niche gaming audience, they didn’t stand out, which might have limited Preston's ability to attract a wider viewership during this period.

Transition Phase: Adding More Vibrancy and Clarity

Various YouTube thumbnail that doesn't follow one single YouTube thumbnail template.

As Preston’s channel began to grow, so did the complexity of his thumbnails. He quickly realized that the first impression a thumbnail makes is crucial for driving clicks, especially in a saturated space like gaming content. This phase marked a shift toward more refined and eye-catching visuals that better represented the high-energy content of his videos.

Design Elements

During this stage, Preston started incorporating more elements into his thumbnails, including character avatars, in-game props, and bold outlines. The use of high-contrast colors also became more prevalent, helping his thumbnails stand out against YouTube’s cluttered interface.

Text Usage

Preston began experimenting with short, impactful text in his thumbnails. Words like “Crazy!” or “Impossible!” were common, and they were often placed in large, bold fonts that were easy to read, even on smaller mobile screens.

Facial Expressions

While in-game screenshots were still a part of his thumbnails, Preston added exaggerated facial expressions. This was a smart move, as human faces—especially ones with clear emotions—can instantly draw attention and connect with viewers on a personal level.

Viewer Impact

This transition greatly improved Preston’s click-through rate (CTR). The added vibrancy, combined with more intentional design choices, made it clear that his content was exciting and worth watching.

Bold Era: High-Impact Thumbnails with Personal Branding

Latest YouTube thumbnail used that have a template for a YouTube thumbnail.

In recent years, Preston has fully embraced what could be considered “high-impact” thumbnails. His designs are now polished, with each thumbnail crafted to visually communicate the theme and excitement of the video. This shift reflects not only his growth as a creator but also a more professional approach to content creation and marketing.

Design Elements

Preston’s current thumbnails are dynamic, featuring multiple layers of high-definition images, vibrant colors, and a clear visual hierarchy. The background typically includes a blurred or simplified version of a game or scene, with the focus being on a central subject—usually Preston himself or a significant game-related element.

Facial Emphasis

One key feature that sets his thumbnails apart now is the focus on Preston’s face. His expressions are more exaggerated, reflecting emotions like shock, excitement, or suspense. This kind of emotional appeal immediately piques curiosity and encourages viewers to click.

Color Contrast

High-contrast colors are a hallmark of his modern thumbnails. Bright yellows, reds, and blues dominate the frames, providing a sharp contrast to darker backgrounds, ensuring that his videos stand out in a sea of content.

Text Integration

Text continues to play a significant role but has been refined. Now, it’s more about complementing the image rather than overpowering it. Words are strategically placed to guide the viewer’s eye, without cluttering the overall design.

Special Effects

Arrows, flames, and bursts of light are often used to draw attention to specific parts of the thumbnail, creating a sense of urgency and action.

Collaborative Thumbnails

When collaborating with other YouTubers like MrBeast or Unspeakable, his thumbnails feature both creators side by side, often showing them engaged in some challenge or competitive activity. These thumbnails are split-screened or layered in a way that emphasizes the excitement of the collaboration.

Viewer Impact

The polished look and high-quality design of these thumbnails have helped Preston maintain a consistently high CTR. His videos now appear more professional and well-produced, appealing to both long-time fans and new viewers.

Key Lessons from Preston’s Thumbnail Evolution

  1. Simplicity Isn’t Always Best: While simple thumbnails might work for small, niche channels, growing YouTubers need to invest in creating more dynamic and vibrant thumbnails to capture viewer attention.
  2. Emphasize Emotion: As seen in Preston’s transition to high-impact thumbnails, including facial expressions that convey emotion can significantly boost a thumbnail’s effectiveness. Whether it’s surprise, excitement, or suspense, emotion creates an instant connection with viewers.
  3. Use of Text and Contrast: Preston’s use of bold, high-contrast colors and well-placed text makes his thumbnails not only stand out but also easy to understand at a glance. This ensures that even viewers quickly scrolling through YouTube can grasp what his video is about and feel compelled to click.
  4. Consistent Branding: One of the most important takeaways from Preston’s journey is the consistency in his branding. Over time, he’s developed a recognizable thumbnail style—vibrant, expressive, and packed with energy. This consistency helps to build a loyal audience and makes his content instantly recognizable.

Preston’s thumbnail journey is an inspiring case study for any content creator looking to improve their own thumbnails. By paying attention to design elements like color contrast, text placement, and emotional appeal, creators can increase their click-through rates and grow their channels just like Preston did.

How Preston’s Thumbnails Stack Up to YouTube’s Thumbnail Guidelines

Preston’s thumbnails hit many of the key points that YouTube suggests for creating custom thumbnails. According to the YouTube thumbnail guidelines, great thumbnails should be high-quality, clear, and expressive. Let's take a look at how Preston's thumbnails compare in the following parameters:

  • Image Balance
  • Contrast
  • Emotions
  • Word Impact
  • Blank Spaces

                  YOUTUBE’s Suggestions for Great Custom Thumbnails


YOUTUBE’s Suggestions for Great Custom Thumbnails
YouTube’ Criteria Preston Score
Image Balance Effective use of symmetry to enhance the thumbnail's aesthetic value. 4/5
Contrast High-resolution images ensure clarity and detail, making thumbnails eye-catching. 3/5
Emotions Emotionally engaging facial expressions 4/5
Lesser Words Text designed to prompt viewers to click as Game-specific elements for context 3/5
Blank Spaces Ensures elements stand out and the thumbnail remains visually appealing. 4/5
Total Score 3.6

Create YouTube Thumbnails, Like Preston

Rizzle, ai thumbnail maker for creating custom thumbnail image like Preston on YouTube thumbnail.

Rizzle offers a variety of AI-powered tools that can help you create thumbnails similar to Preston’s high-impact designs, even if you don’t have professional design experience. Here are some key features of Rizzle that make it a great choice for creating stunning YouTube thumbnails:

  • AI-Generated Thumbnails: Rizzle’s AI-powered custom thumbnail tool helps you quickly generate professional-looking thumbnails that capture attention without needing advanced design skills.
  • Easy-to-Use Templates: With a wide range of pre-made templates, you can create thumbnails that align with your content, saving time while ensuring your design looks polished.
  • Facial Recognition Enhancement: Similar to how Preston uses facial expressions in his thumbnails, Rizzle’s facial recognition feature can help you emphasize key facial features for an emotional and engaging thumbnail.
  • Color Customization: Easily adjust colors and contrast to create high-impact visuals that stand out, just like Preston’s bright, attention-grabbing designs.
  • Add Text Overlays: With Rizzle, you can effortlessly integrate bold text into your thumbnails, ensuring it complements the imagery without overpowering it.
  • Dynamic Effects: Add effects like shadows, highlights, and arrows to guide the viewer’s attention to specific elements, creating a sense of action and excitement in your thumbnails.
  • Quick Editing: Rizzle’s user-friendly interface allows you to make fast adjustments to thumbnail designs, ensuring your thumbnails are always optimized for the latest trends.

These features make Rizzle a powerful and accessible tool for content creators who want to elevate their thumbnail game without the need for expensive software or extensive design knowledge. You can try creating your own stunning thumbnails with Rizzle’s custom thumbnail feature.

Wrapping It up

Preston’s success on YouTube isn’t just due to his fun videos—it’s also thanks to the strategic and engaging thumbnails that draw viewers in. From vibrant colors to expressive faces, Preston nails the art of grabbing attention. And if you’re looking to up your thumbnail game, you don’t need expensive editing software—Rizzle can help you create eye-catching thumbnails that pop and bring more viewers to your channel.

So, why wait? Take inspiration from Preston and start crafting thumbnails that not only represent your content but also attract viewers.

No items found.

Table of Contents